Monday, November 16, 2026

If It Ain't Broke -- Oh. Fix It!

 

When FAA systems go down, we all suffer. Credit: Microsoft Designer

Tell me which you find most believable:

  • Foreign hackers disrupted the FAA’s communications system, forcing a nationwide ground stop;
  • Rogue AI was playing around with our nation’s air traffic control system, causing a nationwide airline ground stop;
  • A contractor replacing an outdated router caused air traffic communications problems that were bad enough to ground all flights.

Well, the Trump Administration, particularly Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and Secretary of Homeland Security Markwayne Mullin, would have us believe the latter. I’m honestly surprised they didn’t try to tell us it was due to “swamp gas” and ask us to look into a Neuralyzer (Gen Z: check your Men in Black references).  

Conspiratorial minds might have pointed to the widespread Microsoft outages just the day before (which Microsoft eventually attributed to “an earlier network capacity upgrade,” or the cyberattacks and bomb threats that had caused havoc in Europe all week. Or today’s widespread bank outages. Sure, it’s a big, complicated world and these might all be unrelated, but at some point Occam’s razor comes into play.

The thing is, though, I kind of believe the Two Stooges. A week earlier the same Sean Duffy boldly announced: “Good news America: floppy disks are out, 21st century tech is in,” as part of a – I kid you not – decades long modernization effort. Even with the announcement, it was expected to take another two years to fully phase the floppy disk out. No one disputes that our air traffic control “system” is running on technology that is long outdated and showing many signs of strain.

And money has been spent to address it. President Biden’s Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act allocated $25 billion over five years to the FAA, and the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 gave the FAA $105.5b, mostly for operations but also for national airspace modernization. Just last year Congress granted the FAA $12.5b for modernization. So, there’s been lots of money allocated, but it’s neither quite clear how much has been spent, nor how much actual modernization that spending has bought.

Now Secretary Duffy wants $50b – to boost the efforts, and claims he could get working on it the next day.  Just days before the request was $30b.

You may remember that in early 2025 Elon Musk promised that DOGE was going “to make rapid safety upgrades to the air traffic control system,” but, of course, that did not happen.

It’s worth pointing out that just two months ago the GAO issued a report on FAA’s modernization efforts, and it was not kind. It noted that there were over 11,000 different active modernization projects, and the FAA had not ensured the schedules were integrated, even for projects installing on the same site at the same time. It lacked a master schedule, and “a reliable lifecycle cost estimate.”  As a result, the GAO found, the FAA “could be prioritizing speed over costs and air traffic disruptions…the agency could end up causing air traffic disruptions or prolonging reliance on severely outdated systems.”

Ya think?

And they want more money?
These are not people you want to blithely give $50b to it. These are not people we should give any additional money to until they can detail what, exactly, they’ve done with the money they already have, and what, exactly, they would do with any existing and new money.

I wish I believed these kinds of problems were limited to the FAA, but I don’t. The IRS, for example, has been working to “modernize” its 1960’s era system all of this century, including with $4.8b allocated by President Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act. The GAO identified 23 IT modernization projects in 2024, but those were paused when President Trump assumed office, so that the IRS could develop a new plan. “Recent changes to IRS' long-term plans have also cast uncertainty over what the agency's modernized end state will look like,” said David Hinchman, director of IT and cybersecurity at GAO.

Former IRS Commissioner Daniel Werfel said: “We still don’t have a modernization plan from the IRS. What we have is this idea that the IRS is going to be more effective once it’s automated, roboticized, and infused with AI.” One IRS IT employee told NextGov: “They are shoving AI at us and they think that with that, things can be converted super quickly. But they don’t have the right tools for us yet.”

Going further, a 2023 GAO report found:

The IRS is just one of many agencies, government-wide, grappling with aging or old IT systems. Of the government’s $100 billion in annual IT spending, 80% goes to operating and maintaining existing systems. The older the systems are, the more the upkeep costs—and, older systems are more vulnerable to hackers.

Pick your most important federal IT system: IRS, Social Security, even Defense; chances are, it is outdated, prone to failure and/or hacking. There are undoubtedly failures every day; we just don’t usually see them, until one of them causes a nationwide ground stop.

It’s worse than that. Pick any big corporation, or, indeed, any corporation that has been around for a few years. Chances are that their systems are not as up-to-date and robust as they should be, and as much they need to be in a world of AI and increased cyberattacks. 

A few years ago Southwest Airline’s systems debacle introduced me to the term “technical debt,” which refers to known software shortcomings that were ignored at the time due to other project priorities/constraints. As I wrote then, that debt is huge, and it is going to come due, some sooner rather than later.

We'll fix that later. Credit: Melv1n
We need people like Jennifer Padlka, co-founder of the U.S. Digital Response and author of Recoding America,. As she said in an interview a few years ago: “We’ve been trying to fix this problem with more money for technology in government, more oversight and more rules. And the evidence shows that’s not working. We got to take a different approach.”

She has her ideas about that approach, which involve giving the people directly involved in the implementation much more say into what is implemented, and how.

Sean Duffy is not one of those people.

Maybe we’ll soon be able to throw our hands up and tell AI to just revamp everything, no need for us to slog through the details. In the meantime, though, I’m not eager to see what the next “router failure” costs us.

No comments:

Post a Comment